top of page

Shoulder Clicking During Overhead Presses? Why Smart Loading May Beat Rest

Writer: Sonny Wilson
Sonny Wilson
Oct 28
13 min read

You're halfway through an overhead press when you feel it: a click, pop or uncomfortable sensation in your shoulder.

Maybe it doesn't hurt. Maybe it's mildly uncomfortable. Or perhaps you've noticed that your shoulder becomes increasingly irritated as your workouts progress.

You back off the weight. You take a few days off. Maybe even a couple of weeks.

Then you return to training, and the same problem is waiting for you.

It's tempting to conclude that your shoulder simply needs more rest. But depending on what's causing the problem, the missing ingredient may actually be the right kind of strength training.

One approach worth understanding is isometric loading: producing muscular force without moving the joint through a range of motion.

Research suggests that isometrics can be a useful component of tendon rehabilitation. But they're not a magic fix, and understanding when and how to use them matters.

First, Does a Clicking Shoulder Mean Something Is Damaged?

Not necessarily.

Shoulders are complex joints. They rely on coordinated movement between the upper arm, shoulder blade, collarbone and surrounding muscles.

Clicking, popping and other joint sounds can occur for several reasons, including tendon movement, changes in joint pressure or interactions between joint structures.

Importantly, a sound alone does not establish that a tendon is damaged.

Consider three situations:

  • Clicking without pain: A shoulder that makes noise but moves comfortably, maintains normal strength and performs everyday activities without difficulty may not require treatment.

  • Clicking with discomfort: Pain during pressing, reaching or lifting deserves attention, particularly when symptoms persist or worsen.

  • Clicking with weakness or instability: New weakness, catching, locking, a sensation that the shoulder may slip out of place or difficulty lifting the arm warrants professional assessment.

The distinction matters because treating every shoulder click as an injury can create unnecessary concern, while ignoring meaningful symptoms can delay appropriate care.

The goal isn't to make every joint perfectly silent.

It's to develop a shoulder that moves well, tolerates load and performs the activities you want it to perform.

Understanding the Rotator Cuff and Shoulder Tendons

The rotator cuff consists of four muscles and their associated tendons:

  • Supraspinatus

  • Infraspinatus

  • Teres minor

  • Subscapularis

Together, these muscles help control and stabilize the shoulder during movement.

When you perform an overhead press, the rotator cuff works alongside the deltoids, shoulder-blade muscles and other supporting structures.

Tendons connect muscles to bones and transmit force. They are living tissues that respond to mechanical loading, although their adaptation can be slower than the strength gains experienced by muscles.

One possible cause of persistent shoulder discomfort is rotator cuff tendinopathy, a condition involving pain and impaired tendon-related function.

However, not every painful shoulder involves tendinopathy. Other possibilities include joint irritation, stiffness, cervical spine-related symptoms, instability or a rotator cuff tear.

That's why a proper assessment matters when symptoms are persistent or significant.

Why Complete Rest Isn't Always the Answer

Rest has an important place in recovery, especially following an acute injury or when an activity is clearly aggravating symptoms.

But there's a difference between temporarily reducing irritating activities and avoiding all shoulder loading for weeks.

For many people with rotator cuff tendinopathy, an appropriately designed exercise program is a recommended first-line treatment.

The 2025 clinical practice guideline published in the Journal of Orthopaedic & Sports Physical Therapy recommends active rehabilitation, which can include resistance training and motor-control exercises at different loads, to improve pain and disability.

This means that for an appropriately assessed shoulder condition, rehabilitation is often about finding the amount and type of activity the shoulder can currently tolerate, then progressively building capacity.

That may involve temporarily reducing overhead pressing while strengthening the shoulder in more comfortable positions.

The objective is not simply to avoid pain. It's to restore the capacity to perform meaningful activities.

Importantly, pain that increases after rest doesn't prove that rest damaged the tendon. Symptoms can fluctuate for several reasons, and an individual response does not establish a diagnosis.

What Is Isometric Training?

Isometric training involves producing muscular tension without visible movement at the joint.

For example, imagine holding a dumbbell stationary halfway through a curl.

Your muscles are working, even though the weight isn't moving.

The same principle can be applied to shoulder exercises.

An isometric shoulder exercise might involve pressing your hand gently into a wall, holding a resistance band at a fixed position or maintaining a supported arm position against resistance.

The potential advantage is that you can apply muscular force in a controlled position without repeatedly moving through an uncomfortable range.

This can make isometrics a practical entry point when dynamic exercises are temporarily difficult.

However, isometric exercises still load tissues. They are not automatically safe or pain-free simply because the joint isn't moving.

What Does the Research Actually Say?

This is where we need to distinguish promising research from conclusions that go beyond the evidence.

The 12-Week Tendon-Stiffness Research

Research by Kubo and colleagues in 2001 investigated how isometric training influences tendon mechanical properties.

In one study, eight participants completed 12 weeks of knee-extension isometric training at approximately 70% of maximum voluntary contraction, using 20-second holds four days per week.

A related study compared short-duration contractions with longer 20-second contractions over 12 weeks.

The longer-duration approach produced measurable changes in tendon mechanical properties, supporting the idea that the duration of muscular tension can influence tendon adaptation.

These findings are interesting because they demonstrate that tendons respond to how loading is applied, not simply whether muscles are exercised.

However, there are important limitations.

These studies examined healthy young adults' knee-extensor tendon structures, not damaged shoulder tendons.

They also used specific research protocols, not the frequently circulated recommendation of 30-second holds at 70% effort several times throughout the day, five or six days per week.

The claim that this exact protocol makes damaged shoulder tendons more than 20% stiffer is therefore not established by these studies.

Furthermore, tendon stiffness is a mechanical property, not a direct measurement of healing or pain relief.

An increase in stiffness may represent adaptation, but it does not automatically mean that a person has recovered from tendinopathy.

Are Isometrics Better Than Regular Strengthening?

Not consistently.

A systematic review published in BMJ Open Sport & Exercise Medicine in 2020 found that isometric exercise was not clearly superior to isotonic exercise for managing chronic tendinopathy.

Isotonic exercises involve movement, such as controlled dumbbell raises, rows and external rotations.

The review also found that the pain-relieving effects of isometrics varied considerably between individuals.

This doesn't mean isometrics are ineffective.

It means they should be understood as one useful training tool within a broader progressive rehabilitation program, rather than a universally superior treatment.

How Isometric Training May Help Your Shoulder

There are several practical reasons a qualified coach or rehabilitation professional might incorporate isometrics into a shoulder-strengthening program.

Controlled Loading

Holding a stable position allows the individual to develop force without repeatedly moving through an uncomfortable portion of an exercise.

For someone whose shoulder becomes irritated during overhead pressing, this may provide a more manageable starting point.

Building Strength in Tolerable Positions

Isometrics can help maintain or develop muscular force production, particularly around the joint angles being trained.

Over time, they may contribute to a broader strength-building program.

However, improvements in one position do not automatically transfer fully to every joint angle or movement.

Potential Short-Term Pain Relief

Some individuals experience reduced tendon-related pain following isometric contractions.

Others experience little change or even increased discomfort.

The response is individual, and pain relief should not be assumed.

Rebuilding Confidence

When a movement has become uncomfortable, people sometimes begin avoiding it altogether.

Appropriately selected isometric exercises can provide an opportunity to experience controlled resistance again.

That can be useful when gradually rebuilding tolerance for more demanding movements.

Three Practical Shoulder Isometrics to Understand

These are examples of exercises a coach or rehabilitation professional may consider after determining that shoulder loading is appropriate.

They are not a diagnosis or a universal rehabilitation prescription.

1. External Rotation Wall Hold

Stand with your elbow bent approximately 90 degrees and tucked comfortably beside your body.

Position the back of your hand against a stable doorframe or wall.

Gently press outward without allowing your arm to move.

Keep your wrist neutral, shoulder relaxed and torso still.

This can provide a controlled way to load the shoulder's external rotators.

2. Shoulder Abduction Wall Hold

Stand sideways near a wall with your elbow bent and upper arm comfortably beside your body.

Press the outside of your arm gently into the wall without lifting your shoulder or leaning your torso.

This can introduce resistance to the shoulder muscles involved in lifting the arm away from the body.

3. Shoulder Flexion Wall Hold

Face a wall with your elbow bent and your fist or forearm resting against it at a comfortable height.

Gently press forward without allowing your body to move.

Keep your neck relaxed and avoid arching your lower back.

This can introduce controlled loading to muscles involved in forward shoulder elevation.

How Long Should You Hold?

There is no single scientifically established hold duration or intensity that works best for every shoulder condition.

For an appropriate, low-irritability exercise, a clinician or coach may begin with brief, submaximal holds of approximately 10–20 seconds and a small number of repetitions, then adjust based on the individual's response.

Longer holds, such as 30 seconds, may be introduced when tolerated.

A prescribed 70% effort can be demanding, particularly for someone with a painful shoulder. It should not automatically be treated as a beginner's starting intensity.

Avoid breath-holding or straining, particularly if you have cardiovascular concerns.

The important variables are the load, position, duration, frequency and how the shoulder responds during and after training.

What About the 30-Second, 70% Effort Protocol?

The original claim proposes 30-second holds at approximately 70% effort, repeated several times throughout the day, five or six days per week.

That may sound precise, but precision does not guarantee that a protocol has been validated for a particular condition.

The evidence does not establish this exact prescription as the optimal treatment for shoulder tendinopathy.

There are several reasons not to apply it universally.

First, 70% effort is difficult to measure accurately without appropriate testing equipment. A person's subjective estimate may differ considerably from their actual force production.

Second, multiple daily loading sessions may be excessive for someone whose shoulder is already highly irritable.

Third, the right training frequency depends on total workload, symptom response, recovery capacity and the other activities being performed.

Finally, different shoulder conditions require different approaches.

A person recovering from a diagnosed rotator cuff tear, for example, may need a very different program from someone experiencing mild exercise-related discomfort.

A good training protocol is not defined by how exact the numbers look. It's defined by whether the dose is appropriate, effective and adaptable to the person performing it.

How to Return to Overhead Pressing

For someone with an assessed, non-urgent shoulder problem who has been cleared to train, the following progression illustrates how a structured return might work.

Stage 1: Establish Comfortable Loading

Begin with appropriately selected isometrics or light dynamic exercises in tolerable positions.

Monitor symptoms during training and the following day.

The initial objective is to identify exercises and loading levels that the shoulder can manage consistently.

Stage 2: Develop Controlled Movement

Introduce light resistance-band or dumbbell exercises, such as external rotations, rows and supported pressing variations, as appropriate.

Emphasize controlled movement and gradually increasing capacity.

Stage 3: Reintroduce Pressing Patterns

Consider movements such as a landmine press or neutral-grip dumbbell press when they are comfortable and suitable for the individual's condition.

A landmine press changes the pressing angle and may be better tolerated by some people, although it is not inherently safer for every shoulder.

Stage 4: Progress Overhead Strength

Gradually increase the range of motion, resistance and training volume while monitoring shoulder function and recovery.

The goal is to rebuild tolerance for the activities that matter to the individual, rather than simply completing a predetermined number of sessions.

This is not a fixed four-week rehabilitation protocol.

Some individuals will progress quickly; others will require a slower approach or different exercises.

The decision to advance should be based on function, symptoms, strength and overall training goals.

What If Your Shoulder Pain Keeps Returning?

If discomfort disappears during a training break but returns whenever you resume pressing, consider the entire training picture.

The problem may involve more than one exercise.

Ask yourself:

  • Training volume: Have you recently increased pressing sets, classes, boxing sessions or total upper-body workload?

  • Load progression: Are you increasing weights faster than your shoulder can tolerate?

  • Exercise selection: Could a different grip, range of motion or pressing angle be more comfortable?

  • Recovery: Are your sleep, training frequency and recovery opportunities sufficient?

  • Movement capacity: Do you have the strength and control required for the exercises you're attempting?

For someone who attends kickboxing classes, performs strength training and adds personal workouts, total shoulder loading can accumulate across the week.

Punching, pressing, push-ups and other upper-body movements all contribute to training demands, even though they load the shoulder differently.

That doesn't mean these activities are harmful.

It means they should be considered together when planning training.

When Should You Seek Professional Assessment?

Not every shoulder click requires a medical appointment, but certain symptoms should not be managed through self-directed loading experiments.

Seek appropriate assessment if you experience:

  • Persistent or worsening shoulder pain

  • Noticeable weakness or loss of movement

  • Repeated catching, locking or instability

  • Pain that substantially affects sleep or daily activities

  • Symptoms that do not improve despite sensible training modifications

A sudden injury accompanied by a pop and marked weakness, visible deformity or inability to lift the arm warrants prompt medical evaluation.

Severe symptoms accompanied by chest pain, shortness of breath or other systemic warning signs require urgent care.

If you've already completed several weeks of sensible exercise modifications without improvement, a physiotherapist or other qualified healthcare professional can help identify the cause and determine an appropriate plan.

A fitness coach can help implement an appropriate training plan within their scope of practice, but should not substitute for a medical diagnosis.

The Bigger Lesson: Tendons Respond to Training, Not Guesswork

There is an important difference between training hard and training effectively.

More repetitions are not always better.

More weight is not always better.

And more rest is not always better.

The goal is to apply an appropriate stimulus, allow sufficient recovery and gradually improve the body's ability to handle physical demands.

Isometrics can play a useful role in that process, particularly when they provide a tolerable way to introduce or maintain muscular loading.

But the most effective long-term approach usually involves more than holding a single position.

It involves progressive strength development, movement control, appropriate exercise selection and adjustments based on individual response.

That's how training becomes sustainable.

Key Takeaways

  • Shoulder clicking without pain does not necessarily indicate an injury.

  • Persistent shoulder pain should be assessed rather than automatically attributed to tendon damage.

  • Complete rest is not always the best long-term strategy for rotator cuff tendinopathy.

  • Isometric exercises provide controlled muscular loading without visible joint movement.

  • Research does not establish isometrics as consistently superior to conventional resistance training.

  • A specific 30-second, 70%-effort protocol has not been established as the universal solution for painful shoulders.

  • Progressive, individualized loading is more useful than repeatedly stopping and restarting training without a plan.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I Stop Overhead Pressing If My Shoulder Clicks?

Not necessarily. Clicking without pain or functional limitation may not require stopping.

If pressing causes pain, weakness or instability, modify the activity and seek assessment when appropriate.

Can Isometric Exercises Repair Damaged Tendons?

Isometric training can contribute to muscular and tendon adaptation, but evidence does not establish that isometrics alone repair every form of tendon damage.

The underlying diagnosis and overall rehabilitation program matter.

Are 30-Second Holds Better Than 10-Second Holds?

Not universally.

Contraction duration influences the training stimulus, but the optimal duration for shoulder rehabilitation remains uncertain.

Individual tolerance and the intended training outcome should guide the prescription.

Should I Do Shoulder Isometrics Every Day?

Some low-load exercises may be performed frequently, but daily loading is not appropriate for everyone.

Intensity, total volume, symptom irritability and other training activities should determine frequency.

Can I Continue Boxing or Kickboxing With Shoulder Discomfort?

That depends on the cause and severity of symptoms.

Punching loads the shoulder repeatedly, so temporary changes in intensity, volume or exercise selection may be appropriate.

Persistent pain or weakness deserves assessment.

How Long Does Tendon Rehabilitation Take?

Improvement may occur over weeks, but persistent tendon-related conditions can require several months of progressive rehabilitation.

Recovery timelines vary, and symptom improvement does not necessarily mean that tendon tissue has fully adapted.

The PuncHIIT Perspective

At PuncHIIT Fitness, we believe that training should have a purpose beyond simply completing another workout.

When someone experiences shoulder discomfort, the answer isn't automatically to stop every upper-body exercise. Nor is it to push through symptoms and hope they disappear.

Instead, we look at the training variables we can reasonably influence: exercise selection, resistance, range of motion, volume, frequency, movement quality and progression.

For one person, that might mean temporarily replacing overhead presses with a more comfortable variation.

For another, it might involve adding controlled rotator cuff strengthening, including isometric exercises where appropriate.

And for someone with persistent symptoms, it may mean recommending an assessment by a physiotherapist before progressing.

Our personal training approach incorporates strength, mobility, movement coaching and individualized programming. We work within our professional scope and collaborate with healthcare providers when needed.

The objective isn't simply to get through today's workout.

It's to build the physical capacity to keep training confidently and sustainably over time.

STOP EXERCISING. START TRAINING.

Ready to Build Stronger, More Capable Shoulders?

If shoulder discomfort has been interfering with your strength training, it may be time to take a more structured approach.

Our personal training team at PuncHIIT Fitness can help you review your exercise technique, modify training demands and develop a progressive strength and mobility program suited to your goals and abilities.

Where symptoms suggest an injury or medical condition, we'll encourage appropriate healthcare assessment before proceeding.

Explore Personal Training at PuncHIIT Fitness

Coach's Corner

Don't confuse movement with progress.

If your shoulder is uncomfortable during overhead pressing, adding more warm-up repetitions or stretching isn't necessarily the answer.

Start by examining what you're asking the shoulder to do.

Can you reduce the weight? Change the pressing angle? Shorten the range of motion temporarily? Introduce controlled strengthening that your shoulder tolerates?

And most importantly, are you tracking whether those adjustments actually improve your training over time?

A useful coaching habit is to record three things:

  • The exercise and load used

  • How your shoulder responded during the session

  • How it felt the following morning

That information can help guide sensible training adjustments and provide useful context for a healthcare professional when needed.

The goal isn't to find one magical shoulder exercise.

It's to develop a training plan that consistently moves you toward better strength and function.

Suggested Internal Links


Personal Training


Mobility Strong


Athletic Performance


Related Reading


The Most Underrated Shoulder Exercise You're Probably Not Doing


Why We Use Isometrics in Rehab


Isometrics Are More Than Holding Still: How Static Strength Builds Force, Control & Performance


Why Tendon Healing Takes Time — And How to Speed It Up Safely


Why Your Tendons Are the Real Limiting Factor in Strength Training


References


1. Desmeules F, et al. (2025). Rotator Cuff Tendinopathy Diagnosis, Nonsurgical Medical Care, and Rehabilitation: A Clinical Practice Guideline. Journal of Orthopaedic & Sports Physical Therapy, 55(4), 235–274.

DOI


2. Kubo K, Kanehisa H, Ito M, Fukunaga T. (2001). Effects of isometric training on the elasticity of human tendon structures in vivo. Journal of Applied Physiology, 91(1), 26–32.

PubMed


3. Kubo K, Kanehisa H, Fukunaga T. (2001). Effects of different duration isometric contractions on tendon elasticity in human quadriceps muscles. The Journal of Physiology, 536(2), 649–655.

PubMed


4. Effectiveness of isometric exercise in the management of tendinopathy: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised trials. (2020). BMJ Open Sport & Exercise Medicine.

Comments


bottom of page